The science of price experiments in the Amazon Store

The requirement that at any given time, all customers see the same prices for the same products necessitates innovation in the design of A/B experiments.

The prices of products in the Amazon Store reflect a range of factors, such as demand, seasonality, and general economic trends. Pricing policies typically involve formulas that take such factors into account; newer pricing policies usually rely on machine learning models.

With the Amazon Pricing Labs, we can conduct a range of online A/B experiments to evaluate new pricing policies. Because we practice nondiscriminatory pricing — all visitors to the Amazon Store at the same time see the same prices for all products — we need to apply experimental treatments to product prices over time, rather than testing different price points simultaneously on different customers. This complicates the experimental design.

Related content
Amazon Scholar David Card on the revolution in economic research that he helped launch and its consequences for industry.

In a paper we published in the Journal of Business Economics in March and presented at the American Economics Association’s annual conference in January (AEA), we described some of the experiments we can conduct to prevent spillovers, improve precision, and control for demand trends and differences in treatment groups when evaluating new pricing policies.

The simplest type of experiment we can perform is a time-bound experiment, in which we apply a treatment to some products in a particular class, while leaving other products in the class untreated, as controls.

Time-bound experiment.png
A time-bound experiment, which begins at day eight, with treatments in red and controls in white.

One potential source of noise in this type of experiment is that an external event — say, a temporary discount on the same product at a different store — can influence treatment effects. If we can define these types of events in advance, we can conduct triggered interventions, in which we time the starts of our treatment and control periods to the occurrence of the events. This can result in staggered start times for experiments on different products.

Triggered interventions.png
The design of a triggered experiment. Red indicates treatment groups, and green indicates control groups. The start of each experiment is triggered by an external event.

If the demand curves for the products are similar enough, and the difference in results between the treatment group and the control group are dramatic enough, time-bound and triggered experiments may be adequate. But for more precise evaluation of a pricing policy, it may be necessary to run treatment and control experiments on the same product, as would be the case with typical A/B testing. That requires a switchback experiment.

Related content
Context vectors that capture “side information” can make experiments more informative.

The most straightforward switchback experiment is the random-days experiments, in which, each day, each product is randomly assigned to either the control group or the treatment group. Our analyses indicate that random days can reduce the standard error of our experimental results — that is, the extent to which the statistics of our observations differ, on average, from the true statistics of the intervention — by 60%.

Random days.png
A random-days experiment. The experiment begins on day 8; red represents treatment, white control.

One of the drawbacks with any switchback experiment, however, is the risk of carryover, in which the effects of a treatment carry over from the treatment phase of the experiment to the control phase. For instance, if treatment increases a product’s sales, recommendation algorithms may recommend that product more often. That could artificially boost the product’s sales even during control periods.

Related content
Pat Bajari, VP and chief economist for Amazon's Core AI group, on his team's new research and what it says about economists' role at Amazon.

We can combat carryover by instituting blackout periods during transitions to treatment and control phases. In a crossover experiment, for instance, we might apply a treatment to some products in a group, leaving the others as controls, but toss out the first week’s data for both groups. Then, after collecting enough data — say, two weeks’ worth — we remove the treatment from the former treatment group and apply it to the former control group. Once again, we throw out the first week’s data, to let the carryover effect die down.

Crossover experiment.png
A crossover experiment, with blackout periods at the beginning of each phase of the experiment. In week 7, the treatment (red) has been applied to products A, D, F, G, and J, but the data is thrown out. In week 10, the first treatment and control groups switch roles, but again, the first week’s data is thrown out.

Crossover experiments can reduce the standard error of our results measurements by 40% to 50%. That’s not quite as good as random days, but carryover effects are mitigated.

Heterogeneous panel treatment effect

The Amazon Pricing Labs also offers two more sophisticated means of evaluating pricing policies. The first of these is the heterogeneous panel treatment effect, or HPTE.

HPTE is a four-step process:

  1. Estimate product-level first difference from detrended data.
  2. Filter outliers.
  3. Estimate second difference from grouped products using causal forest.
  4. Bootstrap data to estimate noise.

Estimate product-level first difference from detrended data. In a standard difference-in-difference (DID) analysis, the first difference is the difference between the results for a single product before and after the experiment begins.

Related content
Amazon Scholar David Card and Amazon academic research consultant Guido Imbens talk about the past and future of empirical economics.

Rather than simply subtracting the results before treatment from the results after treatment, however, we analyze historical trends to predict what would have happened if products were left untreated during the treatment period. We then subtract that prediction from the observed results.

Filter outliers. In pricing experiments, there are frequently unobserved factors that can cause extreme swings in our outcome measurements. We define a cutoff point for outliers as a percentage (quantile) of the results distribution that is inversely proportional to the number of products in the data. This approach has been used previously, but we validated it in simulations.

Estimate second difference from grouped products using causal forest. In DID analysis, the second difference is the difference between the treatment and control groups’ first differences. Because we’re considering groups of heterogeneous products, we calculate the second difference only for products that have strong enough affinities with each other to make the comparison informative. Then we average the second difference across products.

To compute affinity scores, we use a variation on decision trees called causal forests. A typical decision tree is a connected acyclic graph — a tree — each of whose nodes represents a question. In our case, those questions regard product characteristics — say, “Does it require replaceable batteries?”, or “Is its width greater than three inches?”. The answer to the question determines which branch of the tree to follow.

Related content
New method goes beyond Granger causality to identify only the true causes of a target time series, given some graph constraints.

A causal forest consists of many such trees. The questions are learned from the data, and they define the axes along which the data shows the greatest variance. Consequently, the data used to train the trees requires no labeling.

After training our causal forest, we use it to evaluate the products in our experiment. Products from the treatment and control groups that end up at the same terminal node, or leaf, of a tree are deemed similar enough that their second difference should be calculated.

Bootstrap data to estimate noise. To compute the standard error, we randomly sample products from our dataset and calculate their average treatment effect, then return them to the dataset and randomly sample again. Multiple resampling allows us to compute the variance in our outcome measures.

Spillover effect

At the Amazon Pricing Labs, we have also investigated ways to gauge the spillover effect, which occurs when treatment of one product causes a change in demand for another, similar product. This can throw off our measurements of treatment effect.

For instance, if a new pricing policy increases demand for, say, a particular kitchen chair, more customers will view that chair’s product page. Some fraction of those customers, however, may buy a different chair listed on the page’s “Discover similar items” section.

If the second chair is in the control group, its sales may be artificially inflated by the treatment of the first chair, leading to an underestimation of the treatment effect. If the second chair is in the treatment group, the inflation of its sales may lead to an overestimation of the treatment effect.

To correct for the spillover effect, we need to measure it. The first step in that process is to build a graph of products with correlated demand.

Related content
“Group testing” protocols tailored to particularities of the COVID-19 pandemic promise more-informative test results.

We begin with a list of products that are related to each other according to criteria such as their fine-grained classifications in the Amazon Store catalogue. For each pair of related items, we then look at a year’s worth of data to determine whether a change in the price of one affects demand for another. If those connections are strong enough, we join the products by an edge in our substitutable-items graph.

From the graph, we compute the probability that any given pair of substitutable products will find themselves included in the same experiment and which group, treatment or control, they’ll be assigned to. From those probabilities, we can use an inverse probability-weighting schema to estimate the effect of spillover on our observed outcomes.

Estimating spillover effect, however, is not as good as eliminating it. One way to do that is to treat substitutable products as a single product class and assign them to treatment or control groups en masse. This does reduce the power of our experiments, but it gives our business partners confidence that the results aren’t tainted by spillover.

To determine which products to include in each of our product classes, we use a clustering algorithm that searches the substitutable-product graph for regions of dense interconnection and severs those regions connections to the rest of the graph. In an iterative process, this partitions the graph into clusters of closely related products.

In simulations, we found that this clustering process can reduce spillover bias by 37%.

Research areas

Related content

US, CA, Palo Alto
Amazon is the 4th most popular site in the US. Our product search engine, one of the most heavily used services in the world, indexes billions of products and serves hundreds of millions of customers world-wide. We are working on a new initiative to transform our search engine into a shopping engine that assists customers with their shopping missions. We look at all aspects of search CX, query understanding, Ranking, Indexing and ask how we can make big step improvements by applying advanced Machine Learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL) techniques. We’re seeking a thought leader to direct science initiatives for the Search Relevance and Ranking at Amazon. This person will also be a deep learning practitioner/thinker and guide the research in these three areas. They’ll also have the ability to drive cutting edge, product oriented research and should have a notable publication record. This intellectual thought leader will help enhance the science in addition to developing the thinking of our team. This leader will direct and shape the science philosophy, planning and strategy for the team, as we explore multi-modal, multi lingual search through the use of deep learning . We’re seeking an individual that can enhance the science thinking of our team: The org is made of 60+ applied scientists, (2 Principal scientists and 5 Senior ASMs). This person will lead and shape the science philosophy, planning and strategy for the team, as we push into Deep Learning to solve problems like cold start, discovery and personalization in the Search domain. Joining this team, you’ll experience the benefits of working in a dynamic, entrepreneurial environment, while leveraging the resources of Amazon [Earth's most customer-centric internet company]. We provide a highly customer-centric, team-oriented environment in our offices located in Palo Alto, California.
JP, 13, Tokyo
Our mission is to help every vendor drive the most significant impact selling on Amazon. Our team invent, test and launch some of the most innovative services, technology, processes for our global vendors. Our new AVS Professional Services (ProServe) team will go deep with our largest and most sophisticated vendor customers, combining elite client-service skills with cutting edge applied science techniques, backed up by Amazon’s 20+ years of experience in Japan. We start from the customer’s problem and work backwards to apply distinctive results that “only Amazon” can deliver. Amazon is looking for a talented and passionate Applied Science Manager to manage our growing team of Applied Scientists and Business Intelligence Engineers to build world class statistical and machine learning models to be delivered directly to our largest vendors, and working closely with the vendors' senior leaders. The Applied Science Manager will set the strategy for the services to invent, collaborating with the AVS business consultants team to determine customer needs and translating them to a science and development roadmap, and finally coordinating its execution through the team. In this position, you will be part of a larger team touching all areas of science-based development in the vendor domain, not limited to Japan-only products, but collaborating with worldwide science and business leaders. Our current projects touch on the areas of causal inference, reinforcement learning, representation learning, anomaly detection, NLP and forecasting. As the AVS ProServe Applied Science Manager, you will be empowered to expand your scope of influence, and use ProServe as an incubator for products that can be expanded to all Amazon vendors, worldwide. We place strong emphasis on talent growth. As the Applied Science Manager, you will be expected in actively growing future Amazon science leaders, and providing mentoring inside and outside of your team. Key job responsibilities The Applied Science Manager is accountable for: (1) Creating a vision, a strategy, and a roadmap tackling the most challenging business questions from our leading vendors, assess quantitatively their feasibility and entitlement, and scale their scope beyond the ProServe team. (2) Coordinate execution of the roadmap, through direct reports, consisting of scientists and business intelligence engineers. (3) Grow and manage a technical team, actively mentoring, developing, and promoting team members. (4) Work closely with other science managers, program/product managers, and business leadership worldwide to scope new areas of growth, creating new partnerships, and proposing new business initiatives. (5) Act as a technical supervisor, able to assess scientific direction, technical design documents, and steer development efforts to maximize project delivery.
US, NY, New York
Amazon Advertising is one of Amazon's fastest growing and most profitable businesses. As a core product offering within our advertising portfolio, Sponsored Products (SP) helps merchants, retail vendors, and brand owners succeed via native advertising, which grows incremental sales of their products sold through Amazon. The SP team's primary goals are to help shoppers discover new products they love, be the most efficient way for advertisers to meet their business objectives, and build a sustainable business that continuously innovates on behalf of customers. Our products and solutions are strategically important to enable our Retail and Marketplace businesses to drive long-term growth. We deliver billions of ad impressions and millions of clicks and break fresh ground in product and technical innovations every day! The Supply team (within Sponsored Products) is looking for an Applied Scientist to join a fast-growing team with the mandate of creating new ad experiences that elevate the shopping experience for hundreds of millions customers worldwide. The Applied Scientist will take end-to-end ownership of driving new product/feature innovation by applying advanced statistical and machine learning models. The role will handle petabytes of unstructured data (images, text, videos) to extract insights into what metadata can be useful for us to highlight to simplify purchase decisions, and propose new experiences that increase shopper engagement. Why you love this opportunity Amazon is investing heavily in building a world-class advertising business. This team is responsible for defining and delivering a collection of advertising products that drive discovery and sales. Our solutions generate billions in revenue and drive long-term growth for Amazon’s Retail and Marketplace businesses. We deliver billions of ad impressions, millions of clicks daily, and break fresh ground to create world-class products. We are highly motivated, collaborative, and fun-loving team with an entrepreneurial spirit - with a broad mandate to experiment and innovate. Key job responsibilities As an Applied Scientist on this team you will: Build machine learning models and perform data analysis to deliver scalable solutions to business problems. Perform hands-on analysis and modeling with very large data sets to develop insights that increase traffic monetization and merchandise sales without compromising shopper experience. Work closely with software engineers on detailed requirements, technical designs and implementation of end-to-end solutions in production. Design and run A/B experiments that affect hundreds of millions of customers, evaluate the impact of your optimizations and communicate your results to various business stakeholders. Work with scientists and economists to model the interaction between organic sales and sponsored content and to further evolve Amazon's marketplace. Establish scalable, efficient, automated processes for large-scale data analysis, machine-learning model development, model validation and serving. Research new predictive learning approaches for the sponsored products business. Write production code to bring models into production. A day in the life You will invent new experiences and influence customer-facing shopping experiences to help suppliers grow their retail business and the auction dynamics that leverage native advertising; this is your opportunity to work within the fastest-growing businesses across all of Amazon! Define a long-term science vision for our advertising business, driven fundamentally from our customers' needs, translating that direction into specific plans for research and applied scientists, as well as engineering and product teams. This role combines science leadership, organizational ability, technical strength, product focus, and business understanding.
US, CA, Palo Alto
The Amazon Search team creates powerful, customer-focused search solutions and technologies. Whenever a customer visits an Amazon site worldwide and types in a query or browses through product categories, Amazon Search services go to work. We design, develop, and deploy high performance, fault-tolerant distributed search systems used by millions of Amazon customers every day. We are seeking a Principal Scientist with deep expertise in Search. Your responsibility will be to advance the state-of-the-art for search science that leads to world-class products that impact Amazon's customers. Key job responsibilities You will be responsible for defining key research directions, adopting or inventing new machine learning techniques, conducting rigorous experiments, publishing results, and ensuring that research is translated into practice. You will develop long-term strategies, persuade teams to adopt those strategies, propose goals and deliver on them. You will also participate in organizational planning, hiring, mentorship and leadership development. You will be technically fearless and with a passion for building scalable science and engineering solutions. You will serve as a key scientific resource in full-cycle development (conception, design, implementation, testing to documentation, delivery, and maintenance). About the team This is a position on Core Ranking and Experimentation team in Palo Alto, CA. The team works on a variety of topics in search ranking and relevance, such as multi-objective optimization, personalization, and fast online experimentation. We work closely with teams in various parts of the stack to ensure that our science is translated to customer facing products.
US, WA, Bellevue
Amazon is looking for a passionate, talented, and inventive Applied Scientists with a strong machine learning background to help build industry-leading Speech and Language technology. Our mission is to provide a delightful experience to Amazon’s customers by pushing the envelope in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Machine Translation (MT), Natural Language Understanding (NLU), Machine Learning (ML) and Computer Vision (CV). As part of our AI team in Amazon AWS, you will work alongside internationally recognized experts to develop novel algorithms and modeling techniques to advance the state-of-the-art in human language technology. Your work will directly impact millions of our customers in the form of products and services that make use of speech and language technology. You will gain hands on experience with Amazon’s heterogeneous speech, text, and structured data sources, and large-scale computing resources to accelerate advances in spoken language understanding. We are hiring in all areas of human language technology: ASR, MT, NLU, text-to-speech (TTS), and Dialog Management, in addition to Computer Vision.
IN, KA, Bangalore
Amazon is investing heavily in building a world class advertising business and we are responsible for defining and delivering a collection of self-service performance advertising products that drive discovery and sales. Our products are strategically important to our Retail and Marketplace businesses driving long term growth. We deliver billions of ad impressions and millions of clicks daily and are breaking fresh ground to create world-class products. The ATT team, based in Bangalore, is responsible for ensuring that ads are compliant to world-wide advertising policies and are of high quality, leading to higher conversion for the advertisers and providing a great experience for the shoppers. Machine learning, particularly multi-modal data understanding, is fundamental to the way we drive our business, meet our goals and satisfy our customers. ATT team invests in researching and developing state of art models that analyze various type of ad assets – text, audio, images and videos - to ensure compliance to advertising policies. We also help advertisers create more successful ads by creating ML models to assist ad generation as well as to provide data-driven interpretable insights. Key job responsibilities Major responsibilities · Deliver key goals to enhance advertiser experience and protect shopper trust by innovative use of computer vision, NLP and statistical techniques · Drive core business analytics and data science explorations to inform key business decisions and algorithm roadmap · Establish scalable, efficient, automated processes for large scale data analyses, model development, model validation and model implementation · Hire and develop top talent in machine learning and data science and accelerate the pace of innovation in the group · Work proactively with engineering teams and product managers to evangelize new algorithms and drive the implementation of large-scale complex ML models in production
US, WA, Seattle
We are seeking a talented applied researcher to join the Search team responsible for developing reinforcement learning systems for Amazon's shopping experience and delivering it to millions of customers. We believe that shopping on Amazon should be simple, delightful, and full of "wow" moments for everyone.
US, NY, New York
We are looking for detail-oriented, organized, and responsible individuals who are eager to learn how to work with large and complicated data sets. Some knowledge of econometrics, as well as basic familiarity with Python is necessary, and experience with SQL and UNIX would be a plus. These are full-time positions at 40 hours per week, with compensation being awarded on an hourly basis. You will learn how to build data sets and perform applied econometric analysis at Internet speed collaborating with economists, scientists, and product managers. These skills will translate well into writing applied chapters in your dissertation and provide you with work experience that may help you with placement. Roughly 85% of interns from previous cohorts have converted to full time economics employment at Amazon. If you are interested, please send your CV to our mailing list at econ-internship@amazon.com. About the team Amazon's Weblab team enables experimentation at massive scale to help Amazon build better products for customers. A/B testing is in Amazon's DNA and we're at the core of how Amazon innovates on behalf of customers.
US, WA, Seattle
Amazon Advertising is one of Amazon's fastest growing and most profitable businesses, responsible for defining and delivering a collection of advertising products that drive discovery and sales. As a core product offering within our advertising portfolio, Sponsored Products (SP) helps merchants, retail vendors, and brand owners succeed via native advertising, which grows incremental sales of their products sold through Amazon. The SP team's primary goals are to help shoppers discover new products they love, be the most efficient way for advertisers to meet their business objectives, and build a sustainable business that continuously innovates on behalf of customers. Our products and solutions are strategically important to enable our Retail and Marketplace businesses to drive long-term growth. We deliver billions of ad impressions and millions of clicks and break fresh ground in product and technical innovations every day! As an Applied Science Manager in Machine Learning, you will: Directly manage and lead a cross-functional team of Applied Scientists, Data Scientists, Economists, and Business Intelligence Engineers. Develop and manage a research agenda that balances short term deliverables with measurable business impact as well as long term investments. Lead marketplace design and development based on economic theory and data analysis. Provide technical and scientific guidance to team members. Rapidly design, prototype and test many possible hypotheses in a high-ambiguity environment, making use of both quantitative and business judgment Advance the team's engineering craftsmanship and drive continued scientific innovation as a thought leader and practitioner. Develop science and engineering roadmaps, run annual planning, and foster cross-team collaboration to execute complex projects. Perform hands-on data analysis, build machine-learning models, run regular A/B tests, and communicate the impact to senior management. Collaborate with business and software teams across Amazon Ads. Stay up to date with recent scientific publications relevant to the team. Hire and develop top talent, provide technical and career development guidance to scientists and engineers within and across the organization. Why you will love this opportunity: Amazon is investing heavily in building a world-class advertising business. This team defines and delivers a collection of advertising products that drive discovery and sales. Our solutions generate billions in revenue and drive long-term growth for Amazon’s Retail and Marketplace businesses. We deliver billions of ad impressions, millions of clicks daily, and break fresh ground to create world-class products. We are a highly motivated, collaborative, and fun-loving team with an entrepreneurial spirit - with a broad mandate to experiment and innovate. Impact and Career Growth: You will invent new experiences and influence customer-facing shopping experiences to help suppliers grow their retail business and the auction dynamics that leverage native advertising; this is your opportunity to work within the fastest-growing businesses across all of Amazon! Define a long-term science vision for our advertising business, driven from our customers' needs, translating that direction into specific plans for research and applied scientists, as well as engineering and product teams. This role combines science leadership, organizational ability, technical strength, product focus, and business understanding. Team video ~ https://youtu.be/zD_6Lzw8raE
US, CA, Palo Alto
The Amazon Search team creates powerful, customer-focused search and advertising solutions and technologies. Whenever a customer visits an Amazon site worldwide and types in a query or browses through product categories, Amazon Search services go to work. We design, develop, and deploy high performance, fault-tolerant distributed search systems used by millions of Amazon customers every day. Our Search Relevance team works to maximize the quality and effectiveness of the search experience for visitors to Amazon websites worldwide. Amazon’s large scale brings with it unique problems to solve in designing, testing, and deploying relevance models. We are seeking a strong applied Scientist to join the Experimentation Infrastructure and Methods team. This team’s charter is to innovate and evaluate ranking at Amazon Search. In practice, we aim to create infrastructure and metrics, enable new experimental methods, and do proof-of-concept experiments, that enable Search Relevance teams to introduce new features faster, reduce the cost of experimentation, and deliver faster against Search goals. Key job responsibilities You will build search ranking systems and evaluation framework that extend to Amazon scale -- thousands of product types, billions of queries, and hundreds of millions of customers spread around the world. As a Senior Applied Scientist you will find the next set of big improvements to ranking evaluation, get your hands dirty by building models to help understand complexities of customer behavior, and mentor junior engineers and scientists. In addition to typical topics in ranking, we are particularly interested in evaluation, feature selection, explainability. A day in the life Our primary focus is improving search ranking systems. On a day-to-day this means building ML models, analyzing data from your recent A/B tests, and guiding teams on best practices. You will also find yourself in meetings with business and tech leaders at Amazon communicating your next big initiative. About the team We are a team consisting of software engineers and applied scientists. Our interests and activities span machine learning for better ranking, experimentation, statistics for better decision making, and infrastructure to make it all happen efficiently at scale.