How to reduce annotation when evaluating AI systems

By exploiting consistencies across components of ensemble classifiers, a new approach reduces data requirements by up to 89%.

Commercial machine learning systems are trained on examples meant to represent the real world. But the world is constantly changing, and deployed machine learning systems need to be regularly reevaluated, to ensure that their performance hasn’t declined.

Evaluating a deployed AI system means manually annotating data the system has classified, to determine whether those classifications are accurate. But annotation is labor intensive, so it is desirable to minimize the number of samples required to assess the system’s performance.

Many commercial machine learning systems are in fact ensembles of binary classifiers; each classifier “votes” on whether an input belongs to a particular class, and the votes are pooled to produce a final decision.

In a paper we’re presenting at the European Conference on Machine Learning, we show how to reduce the number of random samples required to evaluate ensembles of binary classifiers by exploiting overlaps between the sample sets used to evaluate the individual components.

For example, imagine that an ensemble that has three classifiers, and we need 10 samples each to evaluate the performance of the three classifiers. Evaluating the ensemble requires 40 samples — 10 each for the individual classifiers and 10 for the full ensemble. If 10 of the 40 samples were duplicates, we could make do with 30 annotations. Our paper builds on this intuition.

In an experiment using real data, our approach reduced the number of samples required to evaluate an ensemble by more than 89%, while preserving the accuracy of the evaluation.

We also ran experiments using simulated data that varied the degree of overlap between the sample sets for the individual classifiers. In those experiments, the savings averaged 33%.

Finally, in the paper, we show that our sampling procedure doesn’t introduce any biases into the resulting sample sets, relative to random sampling.

Common ground

Intuitively, randomly chosen samples for the separate components of an ensemble would inevitably include some duplicates. Most of the samples useful for evaluating one model should thus be useful for evaluating the others. The goal is to add in just enough additional samples to be able to evaluate all the models.

We begin by choosing a sample set for the entire ensemble, which we dub the “parent”; the individual models of the ensemble are, by reference, “children”. After finding a set of samples sufficient for evaluating the parent, we expand it to include the first child, then repeat the procedure until the set of samples covers all the children.

Our general approach works with any criterion for evaluating an ensemble’s performance, but in the paper, we use precision — or the percentage of true positives that the classifier correctly identifies — as a running example.

Illustration of set intersections.
In this figure, the set of inputs classified as positive by the parent (right circle, AP) intersects the set of inputs classified as positive by the child (left circle, AC). The intersection (orange-shaded region) between a random sample of AP (orange curve, SP) and AC represents S+, the samples from the parent’s positive set that were also classified as positive by the child. The green-shaded region represents S-, samples from the set of inputs that were classified as positive by the child but not the parent. The sprinkled x’s represent Sremain, additional samples of the inputs classified as positive by the child, required to provide enough samples to get a highly accurate estimate of precision.

We begin with the total set of inputs that the parent has judged to belong to the target class and the total set of inputs that the child has. There’s usually considerable overlap between the two sets; for example, in a majority-vote ensemble composed of three classifiers, the ensemble (parent) classifies an input as positive as long as two of the components (children) do.

From the parent set, we select enough random samples to evaluate the parent. Then we find the intersection between that sample set and the child’s total set of positive classifications (S+ in the figure above). This becomes our baseline sample set for the child.

Next, we draw a random sampling of inputs that the child classified as positive but the parent did not (S-, above). The ratio between the size of this sample and the size of the baseline sample set should be the same as the ratio between the number of inputs that the child — but not the parent — labeled positive and the number of inputs that both labeled positive.

When we add these samples to the baseline sample set, we get a combined sample set that may not be large enough to accurately estimate precision. If needed, we select more samples from the inputs classified as positive by the child. These samples may also have been classified as positive by the parent (Sremain in the figure above).

Recall that we first selected samples from the set where the child and parent agreed, then from the set where the child and parent disagreed. That means that the sample set we have constructed is not truly random, so the next step is to mix together the samples in the combined set.

Reshuffle or resample?

We experimented with two different ways of performing this mixing. In one, we simply reshuffle all the samples in the combined set. In the other, we randomly draw samples from the combined set and add them to a new mixed set, until the mixed set is the same size as the combined set. In both approaches, the end result is that when we pick any element from the sample, we won’t know whether it came from the set where the parent and child agreed or the one where they disagreed.

Visualization of the average savings in samples provided by our approach.
A visualization of the average savings in samples provided by our approach as we varied the amount of overlap between the parent’s and child’s judgments.

In our experiments, we identified a slight trade-off between the results of our algorithm when we used reshuffling to produce the mixed sample set and when we used resampling. Because resampling introduces some redundancies into the mixed set, it requires fewer samples than reshuffling, which increases the savings in sample size versus random sampling.

At the same time, however, it slightly lowers the accuracy of the precision estimate. With reshuffling, our algorithm, on average, slightly outperformed random sampling on our three test data sets, while with resampling, it was slightly less accurate than random sampling.

Overall, the sampling procedure we have developed reduces the sample size. Of course, the amount of savings depends on the overlap between the parent’s and child’s judgments. The greater the overlap, the greater the savings in samples.

Research areas

Related content

US, NY, New York
We are looking for detail-oriented, organized, and responsible individuals who are eager to learn how to work with large and complicated data sets. Some knowledge of econometrics, as well as basic familiarity with Python is necessary, and experience with SQL and UNIX would be a plus. These are full-time positions at 40 hours per week, with compensation being awarded on an hourly basis. You will learn how to build data sets and perform applied econometric analysis at Internet speed collaborating with economists, scientists, and product managers. These skills will translate well into writing applied chapters in your dissertation and provide you with work experience that may help you with placement. Roughly 85% of previous cohorts have converted to full time economics employment at Amazon. If you are interested, please send your CV to our mailing list at econ-internship@amazon.com.
FR, Clichy
The role can be based in any of our EU offices. Amazon Supply Chain forms the backbone of the fastest growing e-commerce business in the world. The sheer growth of the business and the company's mission "to be Earth’s most customer-centric company” makes the customer fulfillment business bigger and more complex with each passing year. The EU SC Science Optimization team is looking for a Science leader to tackle complex and ambiguous forecasting and optimization problems for our EU fulfillment network. The team owns the optimization of our Supply Chain from our suppliers to our customers. We are also responsible for analyzing the performance of our Supply Chain end-to-end and deploying Statistics, Econometrics, Operations Research and Machine Learning models to improve decision making within our organization, including forecasting, planning and executing our network. We work closely with Supply Chain Optimization Technology (SCOT) teams, who own the systems and the inputs we rely on to plan our networks, the worldwide scientific community, and with our internal EU stakeholders within Supply Chain, Transportation, Store and Finance. The ideal candidate has a well-rounded-technical/science background as well as a history of leading large projects end-to-end, and is comfortable in developing long term research strategy while ensuring the delivery of incremental results in an ever-changing operational environment. As a Sr. Science Manager, you will lead and grow a high-performing team of data and research scientists, technical program managers and business intelligence engineers. You will partner with operations, finance, store, science and engineering leadership to identify opportunities to drive efficiency improvement in our Fulfillment Center network flows via optimization and scalable execution. As a science leader, you will not only develop optimization solutions, but also influence strategy and outcomes across multiple partner science teams such as forecasting, transportation network design, or modelling teams. You will identify new areas of investment and research and work to align roadmaps to deliver on these opportunities. This role is inherently cross-functional and requires an ability to communicate, influence and earn the trust of science, technical, operations and business leadership.
US, WA, Bellevue
We are looking for detail-oriented, organized, and responsible individuals who are eager to learn how to work with large and complicated data sets. Some knowledge of econometrics, as well as basic familiarity with Python is necessary, and experience with SQL and UNIX would be a plus. These are full-time positions at 40 hours per week, with compensation being awarded on an hourly basis. You will learn how to build data sets and perform applied econometric analysis at Internet speed collaborating with economists, scientists, and product managers. These skills will translate well into writing applied chapters in your dissertation and provide you with work experience that may help you with placement. Roughly 85% of previous cohorts have converted to full time economics employment at Amazon. If you are interested, please send your CV to our mailing list at econ-internship@amazon.com. Key job responsibilities Estimate econometric models using large datasets. Must know SQL and Matlab.
US, WA, Seattle
The AWS AI Labs team has a world-leading team of researchers and academics, and we are looking for world-class colleagues to join us and make the AI revolution happen. Our team of scientists have developed the algorithms and models that power AWS computer vision services such as Amazon Rekognition and Amazon Textract. As part of the team, we expect that you will develop innovative solutions to hard problems, and publish your findings at peer reviewed conferences and workshops. AWS is the world-leading provider of cloud services, has fostered the creation and growth of countless new businesses, and is a positive force for good. Our customers bring problems which will give Applied Scientists like you endless opportunities to see your research have a positive and immediate impact in the world. You will have the opportunity to partner with technology and business teams to solve real-world problems, have access to virtually endless data and computational resources, and to world-class engineers and developers that can help bring your ideas into the world. Our research themes include, but are not limited to: few-shot learning, transfer learning, unsupervised and semi-supervised methods, active learning and semi-automated data annotation, large scale image and video detection and recognition, face detection and recognition, OCR and scene text recognition, document understanding, 3D scene and layout understanding, and geometric computer vision. For this role, we are looking for scientist who have experience working in the intersection of vision and language. We are located in Seattle, Pasadena, Palo Alto (USA) and in Haifa and Tel Aviv (Israel).
US, WA, Seattle
Amazon Prime Video is changing the way millions of customers enjoy digital content. Prime Video delivers premium content to customers through purchase and rental of movies and TV shows, unlimited on-demand streaming through Amazon Prime subscriptions, add-on channels like Showtime and HBO, and live concerts and sporting events like NFL Thursday Night Football. In total, Prime Video offers nearly 200,000 titles and is available across a wide variety of platforms, including PCs and Macs, Android and iOS mobile devices, Fire Tablets and Fire TV, Smart TVs, game consoles, Blu-ray players, set-top-boxes, and video-enabled Alexa devices. Amazon believes so strongly in the future of video that we've launched our own Amazon Studios to produce original movies and TV shows, many of which have already earned critical acclaim and top awards, including Oscars, Emmys and Golden Globes. The Global Consumer Engagement team within Amazon Prime Video builds product and technology solutions that drive customer activation and engagement across all our supported devices and global footprint. We obsess over finding effective, programmatic and scalable ways to reach customers via a broad portfolio of both in-app and out-of-app experiences. We would love to have you join us to build models that can classify and detect content available on Prime Video. We need you to analyze the video, audio and textual signal streams and improve state-of-art solutions while being scalable to Amazon size data. We need to solve problems across many cultures and languages, working alongside an operations team generating labels across many languages to help us achieve these goals. Our team consistently strives to innovate, and holds several novel patents and inventions in the motion picture and television industry. We are highly motivated to extend the state of the art. As a member of our team, you will apply your deep knowledge of Computer Vision and Machine Learning to concrete problems that have broad cross-organizational, global, and technology impact. Your work will focus on addressing fundamental computer vision models like video understanding and video summarization in addition to building appropriate large scale datasets. You will work on large engineering efforts that solve significantly complex problems facing global customers. You will be trusted to operate with independence and are often assigned to focus on areas with significant impact on audience satisfaction. You must be equally comfortable with digging in to customer requirements as you are drilling into design with development teams and developing production ready learning models. You consistently bring strong, data-driven business and technical judgment to decisions. You will work with internal and external stakeholders, cross-functional partners, and end-users around the world at all levels. Our team makes a big impact because nothing is more important to us than pleasing our customers, continually earning their trust, and thinking long term. You are empowered to bring new technologies and deep learning approaches to your solutions. We embrace the challenges of a fast paced market and evolving technologies, paving the way to universal availability of content. You will be encouraged to see the big picture, be innovative, and positively impact millions of customers. This is a young and evolving business where creativity and drive will have a lasting impact on the way video is enjoyed worldwide.
US, CA, Palo Alto
Join a team working on cutting-edge science to innovate search experiences for Amazon shoppers! Amazon Search helps customers shop with ease, confidence and delight WW. We aim to transform Search from an information retrieval engine to a shopping engine. In this role, you will build models to generate and recommend search queries that can help customers fulfill their shopping missions, reduce search efforts and let them explore and discover new products. You will also build models and applications that will increase customer awareness of related products and product attributes that might be best suited to fulfill the customer needs. Key job responsibilities On a day-to-day basis, you will: Design, develop, and evaluate highly innovative, scalable models and algorithms; Design and execute experiments to determine the impact of your models and algorithms; Work with product and software engineering teams to manage the integration of successful models and algorithms in complex, real-time production systems at very large scale; Share knowledge and research outcomes via internal and external conferences and journal publications; Project manage cross-functional Machine Learning initiatives. About the team The mission of Search Assistance is to improve search feature by reducing customers’ effort to search. We achieve this through three customer-facing features: Autocomplete, Spelling Correction and Related Searches. The core capability behind the three features is backend service Query Recommendation.
US, CA, Palo Alto
Amazon is investing heavily in building a world class advertising business and we are responsible for defining and delivering a collection of self-service performance advertising products that drive discovery and sales. Our products are strategically important to our Retail and Marketplace businesses driving long term growth. We deliver billions of ad impressions and millions of clicks daily and are breaking fresh ground to create world-class products. We are highly motivated, collaborative and fun-loving with an entrepreneurial spirit and bias for action. With a broad mandate to experiment and innovate, we are growing at an unprecedented rate with a seemingly endless range of new opportunities. The Ad Response Prediction team in Sponsored Products organization build advanced deep-learning models, large-scale machine-learning (ML) pipelines, and real-time serving infra to match shoppers’ intent to relevant ads on all devices, for all contexts and in all marketplaces. Through precise estimation of shoppers’ interaction with ads and their long-term value, we aim to drive optimal ads allocation and pricing, and help to deliver a relevant, engaging and delightful ads experience to Amazon shoppers. As the business and the complexity of various new initiatives we take continues to grow, we are looking for energetic, entrepreneurial, and self-driven science leaders to join the team. Key job responsibilities As a Principal Applied Scientist in the team, you will: Seek to understand in depth the Sponsored Products offering at Amazon and identify areas of opportunities to grow our business via principled ML solutions. Mentor and guide the applied scientists in our organization and hold us to a high standard of technical rigor and excellence in ML. Design and lead organization wide ML roadmaps to help our Amazon shoppers have a delightful shopping experience while creating long term value for our sellers. Work with our engineering partners and draw upon your experience to meet latency and other system constraints. Identify untapped, high-risk technical and scientific directions, and simulate new research directions that you will drive to completion and deliver. Be responsible for communicating our ML innovations to the broader internal & external scientific community.
US, CA, Palo Alto
We’re working to improve shopping on Amazon using the conversational capabilities of large language models, and are searching for pioneers who are passionate about technology, innovation, and customer experience, and are ready to make a lasting impact on the industry. You'll be working with talented scientists, engineers, and technical program managers (TPM) to innovate on behalf of our customers. If you're fired up about being part of a dynamic, driven team, then this is your moment to join us on this exciting journey!"?
US, CA, Santa Clara
AWS AI/ML is looking for world class scientists and engineers to join its AI Research and Education group working on foundation models, large-scale representation learning, and distributed learning methods and systems. At AWS AI/ML you will invent, implement, and deploy state of the art machine learning algorithms and systems. You will build prototypes and innovate on new representation learning solutions. You will interact closely with our customers and with the academic and research communities. You will be at the heart of a growing and exciting focus area for AWS and work with other acclaimed engineers and world famous scientists. Large-scale foundation models have been the powerhouse in many of the recent advancements in computer vision, natural language processing, automatic speech recognition, recommendation systems, and time series modeling. Developing such models requires not only skillful modeling in individual modalities, but also understanding of how to synergistically combine them, and how to scale the modeling methods to learn with huge models and on large datasets. Join us to work as an integral part of a team that has diverse experiences in this space. We actively work on these areas: * Hardware-informed efficient model architecture, training objective and curriculum design * Distributed training, accelerated optimization methods * Continual learning, multi-task/meta learning * Reasoning, interactive learning, reinforcement learning * Robustness, privacy, model watermarking * Model compression, distillation, pruning, sparsification, quantization About Us Inclusive Team Culture Here at AWS, we embrace our differences. We are committed to furthering our culture of inclusion. We have ten employee-led affinity groups, reaching 40,000 employees in over 190 chapters globally. We have innovative benefit offerings, and host annual and ongoing learning experiences, including our Conversations on Race and Ethnicity (CORE) and AmazeCon (gender diversity) conferences. Amazon’s culture of inclusion is reinforced within our 14 Leadership Principles, which remind team members to seek diverse perspectives, learn and be curious, and earn trust. Work/Life Balance Our team puts a high value on work-life balance. It isn’t about how many hours you spend at home or at work; it’s about the flow you establish that brings energy to both parts of your life. We believe striking the right balance between your personal and professional life is critical to life-long happiness and fulfillment. We offer flexibility in working hours and encourage you to find your own balance between your work and personal lives. Mentorship & Career Growth Our team is dedicated to supporting new members. We have a broad mix of experience levels and tenures, and we’re building an environment that celebrates knowledge sharing and mentorship. Our senior members enjoy one-on-one mentoring and thorough, but kind, code reviews. We care about your career growth and strive to assign projects based on what will help each team member develop into a better-rounded engineer and enable them to take on more complex tasks in the future.
US, WA, Seattle
Do you want to join an innovative team of scientists who use machine learning to help Amazon provide the best experience to our Selling Partners by automatically understanding and addressing their challenges, needs and opportunities? Do you want to build advanced algorithmic systems that are powered by state-of-art ML, such as Natural Language Processing, Large Language Models, Deep Learning, Computer Vision and Causal Modeling, to seamlessly engage with Sellers? Are you excited by the prospect of analyzing and modeling terabytes of data and creating cutting edge algorithms to solve real world problems? Do you like to build end-to-end business solutions and directly impact the profitability of the company and experience of our customers? Do you like to innovate and simplify? If yes, then you may be a great fit to join the Selling Partner Experience Science team. Key job responsibilities Use statistical and machine learning techniques to create the next generation of the tools that empower Amazon's Selling Partners to succeed. Design, develop and deploy highly innovative models to interact with Sellers and delight them with solutions. Work closely with teams of scientists and software engineers to drive real-time model implementations and deliver novel and highly impactful features. Establish scalable, efficient, automated processes for large scale data analyses, model development, model validation and model implementation. Research and implement novel machine learning and statistical approaches. Lead strategic initiatives to employ the most recent advances in ML in a fast-paced, experimental environment. Drive the vision and roadmap for how ML can continually improve Selling Partner experience. About the team Selling Partner Experience Science (SPeXSci) is a growing team of scientists, engineers and product leaders engaged in the research and development of the next generation of ML-driven technology to empower Amazon's Selling Partners to succeed. We draw from many science domains, from Natural Language Processing to Computer Vision to Optimization to Economics, to create solutions that seamlessly and automatically engage with Sellers, solve their problems, and help them grow. Focused on collaboration, innovation and strategic impact, we work closely with other science and technology teams, product and operations organizations, and with senior leadership, to transform the Selling Partner experience.