How to do fast, accurate multi-category classification

Many of today’s most useful AI systems are multilabel classifiers: they map input data into multiple categories at once. An object recognizer, for instance, might classify a given image as containing sky, sea, and boats but not desert or clouds.

Earlier this month, at the International Conference on Machine Learning, my colleagues and I presented a new approach to doing computationally efficient multilabel classification. In tests, we compared our approach to four leading alternatives using three different data sets. On five different performance measures, our system demonstrated improvements across the board.

The need for multilabel classification arises in many different contexts. Originally, it was investigated as a means of doing text classification: a single news article, for instance, might touch on multiple topics. Since then, it’s been used for everything from predicting protein function from raw sequence data to classifying audio files by genre.

The challenge of multilabel classification is to capture dependencies between different labels. If an image features sea, for instance, it’s much more likely to also feature boats than an image that features desert. In principle, the way to capture such dependencies is to learn a joint probability, which represents the likelihood of any combination of probabilities for all labels.

In practice, calculating an accurate joint probability for more than a handful of labels requires an impractically large amount of data. Two years ago, at NeurIPS, my colleagues and I demonstrated that using recurrent neural networks to chain single-label classifiers in sequence was a more computationally efficient way to capture label dependencies. Recurrent neural networks, or RNNs, process sequenced inputs in order, so that the output corresponding to any given input factors in the inputs and outputs that preceded it. RNNs thus automatically consider dependencies.

Our earlier paper, however, assumed that the order in which the classifiers are applied is fixed, regardless of context. Order matters because errors by classifiers early in the chain propagate through subsequent classifications. If the classifier chain erroneously labels an image as containing sea, for instance, it becomes more likely to mislabel it as containing boats.

The way to combat this problem is to move more error-prone classifiers later in the chain. But a given classifier’s propensity for error is relative to its inputs: some classifiers are very reliable for certain types of data but unreliable for others.

Our new approach is to train a system to dynamically vary the order in which the chained classifiers process the inputs, according to features of the input data. This ensures that the classifiers that are most error prone relative to a particular input move to the back of the chain.

In our experiments, we explored two different techniques for doing this. Our first technique used an RNN to generate a sequence of labels for a particular input. Then we excised the erroneous labels while preserving the order of the correct ones. If the resulting sequence omitted any correct labels, we appended them at the end in a random order. This new sequence then became a target output, which we used to re-train the RNN on the same input data.

Multilabel-classification_targets.png._CB442727461_.png
In this example, the numbers 1–5 represent the correct labels for a single input to a recurrent neural network (RNN). The RNN outputs a sequence of labels, some of which are correct (blue) but most of which are wrong (red). We excise the erroneous labels, preserving the order of the correct ones, and append all the missing labels (green) in a random order. This new sequence serves as a target output for re-training the RNN on the same data.

By preserving the order of the correct labels, we ensure that classifiers later in the chain learn to take advantage of classifications earlier in the chain. Initially, the output of the RNN is entirely random, but it eventually learns to tailor its label sequences to the input data. Note that while the training data is annotated to indicate the true labels, it is not annotated to indicate the ideal sequence of classifications. Hence the need for us to generate new training targets on the fly.

Reinforcement learning is the second technique we used to train an RNN to do dynamic classifier chaining. In reinforcement learning, a machine learning system learns a “policy,” which consists of a set of actions to take under different circumstances. It learns the policy through trial and error, gauging its success according to a “reward function”, which measures how far a selected action takes it toward some predefined goal.

In our case, the actions were simply the applications of labels to the input data, and the reward function measured the accuracy of the classification that resulted from the chain of classifiers.

In tests, we compared our systems to four different baselines. Each adopted a different strategy for determining classifier order. Two chained classifiers according to how common their labels were, the third used an arbitrary but fixed ordering, and the fourth generated a separate arbitrary ordering for each input.

We used five different metrics to evaluate system performance. One considered only the accuracy of the single most probable label, two the accuracies of the three most probable labels, and two the accuracies of the five most probable labels. For the three-label and five-label cases, we used two different evaluation strategies. One measured overall accuracy across labels, while the other assigned greater value to accurate assessments of the first few labels.

Our best-performing system combined the outputs of our two dynamic-chaining algorithms to produce a composite classification. On each of the five metrics, and on three different data sets, that combination outperformed whichever of the four baselines offered the best performance, usually by about 2% to 3% and in one instance by nearly 5%.

Research areas

Related content

CA, ON, Toronto
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Are you a Masters student interested in machine learning, natural language processing, computer vision, automated reasoning, or robotics? We are looking for skilled scientists capable of putting theory into practice through experimentation and invention, leveraging science techniques and implementing systems to work on massive datasets in an effort to tackle never-before-solved problems. A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. As an Applied Science Intern, you will own the design and development of end-to-end systems. You’ll have the opportunity to create technical roadmaps, and drive production level projects that will support Amazon Science. You will work closely with Amazon scientists, and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Our scientists use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science.
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. We are looking for Masters or PhD students excited about working on Automated Reasoning or Storage System problems at the intersection of theory and practice to drive innovation and provide value for our customers. AWS Automated Reasoning teams deliver tools that are called billions of times daily. Amazon development teams are integrating automated-reasoning tools such as Dafny, P, and SAW into their development processes, raising the bar on the security, durability, availability, and quality of our products. AWS Automated Reasoning teams are changing how computer systems built on top of the cloud are developed and operated. AWS Automated Reasoning teams work in areas including: Distributed proof search, SAT and SMT solvers, Reasoning about distributed systems, Automating regulatory compliance, Program analysis and synthesis, Security and privacy, Cryptography, Static analysis, Property-based testing, Model-checking, Deductive verification, compilation into mainstream programming languages, Automatic test generation, and Static and dynamic methods for concurrent systems. AWS Storage Systems teams manage trillions of objects in storage, retrieving them with predictable low latency, building software that deploys to thousands of hosts, achieving 99.999999999% (you didn’t read that wrong, that’s 11 nines!) durability. AWS storage services grapple with exciting problems at enormous scale. Amazon S3 powers businesses across the globe that make the lives of customers better every day, and forms the backbone for applications at all scales and in all industries ranging from multimedia to genomics. This scale and data diversity requires constant innovation in algorithms, systems and modeling. AWS Storage Systems teams work in areas including: Error-correcting coding and durability modeling, system and distributed system performance optimization and modeling, designing and implementing distributed, multi-tenant systems, formal verification and strong, practical assurances of correctness, bits-IOPS-Watts: the interplay between computation, performance, and energy, data compression - both general-purpose and domain specific, research challenges with storage media, both existing and emerging, and exploring the intersection between storage and quantum technologies. As an Applied Science Intern, you will work closely with Amazon scientists and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. A successful candidate will be a self-starter with strong attention to detail and the ability to thrive in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment who is comfortable with ambiguity. Amazon believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the world’s most customer-centric company. Our ability to have impact at scale allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in Automated Reasoning and related fields. Our scientists work backwards to produce innovative solutions that delight our customers. Please visit https://www.amazon.science (https://www.amazon.science/) for more information.
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Help us develop the algorithms and models that power computer vision services at Amazon, such as Amazon Rekognition, Amazon Go, Visual Search, and more! We are combining computer vision, mobile robots, advanced end-of-arm tooling and high-degree of freedom movement to solve real-world problems at huge scale. As an intern, you will help build solutions where visual input helps the customers shop, anticipate technological advances, work with leading edge technology, focus on highly targeted customer use-cases, and launch products that solve problems for Amazon customers. A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. You will own the design and development of end-to-end systems and have the opportunity to write technical white papers, create technical roadmaps, and drive production level projects that will support Amazon Science. You will work closely with Amazon scientists, and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Amazon Scientist use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Are you a Masters or PhD student interested in machine learning? We are looking for skilled scientists capable of putting Machine Learning theory into practice through experimentation and invention, leveraging machine learning techniques (such as random forest, Bayesian networks, ensemble learning, clustering, etc.), and implementing learning systems to work on massive datasets in an effort to tackle never-before-solved problems. A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. As an Applied Science Intern, you will own the design and development of end-to-end systems. You’ll have the opportunity to create technical roadmaps, and drive production level projects that will support Amazon Science. You will work closely with Amazon scientists, and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Our scientists use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science.
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Do you have a strong machine learning background and want to help build new speech and language technology? Amazon is looking for Master's students who are ready to tackle some of the most interesting research problems on the leading edge of natural language processing. We are hiring in all areas of spoken language understanding: NLP, NLU, ASR, text-to-speech (TTS), and more! A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. As an Applied Science Intern, you will develop and implement novel scalable algorithms and modeling techniques to advance the state-of-the-art in technology areas at the intersection of ML, NLP, search, and deep learning. You will work side-by-side with global experts in speech and language to solve challenging groundbreaking research problems on production scale data. The ideal candidate must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. Please visit our website to stay updated with the research our teams are working on: https://www.amazon.science/research-areas/conversational-ai-natural-language-processing
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. The Research team at Amazon works passionately to apply cutting-edge advances in technology to solve real-world problems. Do you have a strong machine learning background and want to help build new speech and language technology? Do you welcome the challenge to apply optimization theory into practice through experimentation and invention? Would you love to help us develop the algorithms and models that power computer vision services at Amazon, such as Amazon Rekognition, Amazon Go, Visual Search, etc? At Amazon we hire research science interns to work in a number of domains including Operations Research, Optimization, Speech Technologies, Computer Vision, Robotics, and more! As an intern, you will be challenged to apply theory into practice through experimentation and invention, develop new algorithms using mathematical programming techniques for complex problems, implement prototypes and work with massive datasets. Amazon has a culture of data-driven decision-making, and the expectation is that analytics are timely, accurate, innovative and actionable. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Amazon Scientist use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science.
CA, ON, Toronto
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Are you a PhD student interested in machine learning, natural language processing, computer vision, automated reasoning, or robotics? We are looking for skilled scientists capable of putting theory into practice through experimentation and invention, leveraging science techniques and implementing systems to work on massive datasets in an effort to tackle never-before-solved problems. A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. As an Applied Science Intern, you will own the design and development of end-to-end systems. You’ll have the opportunity to create technical roadmaps, and drive production level projects that will support Amazon Science. You will work closely with Amazon scientists, and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Our scientists use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science.
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. We are looking for PhD students excited about working on Automated Reasoning or Storage System problems at the intersection of theory and practice to drive innovation and provide value for our customers. AWS Automated Reasoning teams deliver tools that are called billions of times daily. Amazon development teams are integrating automated-reasoning tools such as Dafny, P, and SAW into their development processes, raising the bar on the security, durability, availability, and quality of our products. AWS Automated Reasoning teams are changing how computer systems built on top of the cloud are developed and operated. AWS Automated Reasoning teams work in areas including: Distributed proof search, SAT and SMT solvers, Reasoning about distributed systems, Automating regulatory compliance, Program analysis and synthesis, Security and privacy, Cryptography, Static analysis, Property-based testing, Model-checking, Deductive verification, compilation into mainstream programming languages, Automatic test generation, and Static and dynamic methods for concurrent systems. AWS Storage Systems teams manage trillions of objects in storage, retrieving them with predictable low latency, building software that deploys to thousands of hosts, achieving 99.999999999% (you didn’t read that wrong, that’s 11 nines!) durability. AWS storage services grapple with exciting problems at enormous scale. Amazon S3 powers businesses across the globe that make the lives of customers better every day, and forms the backbone for applications at all scales and in all industries ranging from multimedia to genomics. This scale and data diversity requires constant innovation in algorithms, systems and modeling. AWS Storage Systems teams work in areas including: Error-correcting coding and durability modeling, system and distributed system performance optimization and modeling, designing and implementing distributed, multi-tenant systems, formal verification and strong, practical assurances of correctness, bits-IOPS-Watts: the interplay between computation, performance, and energy, data compression - both general-purpose and domain specific, research challenges with storage media, both existing and emerging, and exploring the intersection between storage and quantum technologies. As an Applied Science Intern, you will work closely with Amazon scientists and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. A successful candidate will be a self-starter with strong attention to detail and the ability to thrive in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment who is comfortable with ambiguity. Amazon believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the world’s most customer-centric company. Our ability to have impact at scale allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in Automated Reasoning and related fields. Our scientists work backwards to produce innovative solutions that delight our customers. Please visit https://www.amazon.science (https://www.amazon.science/) for more information.
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Help us develop the algorithms and models that power computer vision services at Amazon, such as Amazon Rekognition, Amazon Go, Visual Search, and more! We are combining computer vision, mobile robots, advanced end-of-arm tooling and high-degree of freedom movement to solve real-world problems at huge scale. As an intern, you will help build solutions where visual input helps the customers shop, anticipate technological advances, work with leading edge technology, focus on highly targeted customer use-cases, and launch products that solve problems for Amazon customers. A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. You will own the design and development of end-to-end systems and have the opportunity to write technical white papers, create technical roadmaps, and drive production level projects that will support Amazon Science. You will work closely with Amazon scientists, and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Amazon Scientist use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science
US, WA, Seattle
To ensure a great internship experience, please keep these things in mind. This is a full time internship and requires an individual to work 40 hours a week for the duration of the internship. Amazon requires an intern to be located where their assigned team is. Amazon is happy to provide relocation and housing assistance if you are located 50 miles or further from the office location. Are you a PhD student interested in machine learning? We are looking for skilled scientists capable of putting Machine Learning theory into practice through experimentation and invention, leveraging machine learning techniques (such as random forest, Bayesian networks, ensemble learning, clustering, etc.), and implementing learning systems to work on massive datasets in an effort to tackle never-before-solved problems. A successful candidate will be a self-starter comfortable with ambiguity, strong attention to detail, and the ability to work in a fast-paced, ever-changing environment. As an Applied Science Intern, you will own the design and development of end-to-end systems. You’ll have the opportunity to create technical roadmaps, and drive production level projects that will support Amazon Science. You will work closely with Amazon scientists, and other science interns to develop solutions and deploy them into production. The ideal scientist must have the ability to work with diverse groups of people and cross-functional teams to solve complex business problems. Amazon Science gives insight into the company’s approach to customer-obsessed scientific innovation. Amazon fundamentally believes that scientific innovation is essential to being the most customer-centric company in the world. It’s the company’s ability to have an impact at scale that allows us to attract some of the brightest minds in artificial intelligence and related fields. Our scientists use our working backwards method to enrich the way we live and work. For more information on the Amazon Science community please visit https://www.amazon.science.