Why do customers buy seemingly irrelevant products?

Analysis points to better algorithms for product discovery.

Product search algorithms, like the ones that help customers place orders through Alexa, aim at returning the products that are most relevant to users’ queries, where relevance is usually interpreted as “anything that satisfies the users’ need”. A common way to estimate customers’ satisfaction is to rely on the judgment of human annotators. (We annotate a very small fraction of 1% of interactions.)

We’ve noticed that customers frequently engage with voice shopping results that annotators label as irrelevant. At this year’s ACM Web Search and Data Mining (WSDM) conference, in February, we will present a systematic analysis of this phenomenon.

Relevance to "buy burger"
Human annotators agreed that Angus burgers were relevant to the voice request “buy burgers”, while a stuffed-burger press was not. But customers who issued that request occasionally bought the burger press, while never buying the burgers.
Stacy Reilly

Our paper presents hypotheses about the reasons for customers’ engagement with seemingly irrelevant results, data that support those hypotheses, and suggestions about how our findings could improve the algorithms voice assistants use to help customers discover products.

The paper explains our methodology in detail, but briefly, my colleagues — David Carmel, Elad Haramaty, Arnon Lazerson, and Yoelle Maarek — and I analyzed two different types of customer interactions with seemingly irrelevant products. The first was purchases, and the second was “engagements”, defined as interactions such as sending a search result to a cell phone or adding a product to the shopping cart.

Our analysis suggests that customers’ likelihood of buying or engaging with seemingly irrelevant products is higher for products that are broadly popular on Amazon and for products that are cheaper than the “relevant” products for a given query. Customers are also much more likely to buy/engage with irrelevant products in a few categories — such as toys and digital products — than in others — such as beauty products and groceries.

We also found that customers who have issued either very short or unusually long queries tend to be more flexible than customers whose queries are of medium length. We used query length as a proxy for specificity: a general (short) query suggests uncertainty and willingness to explore; a specific (long) query decreases the likelihood of an exact match, which makes settling for an approximate match more probable.

Finally, we considered what we call indirect relationships between relevant and irrelevant products. For example, two products have an indirect relationship if they are of the same type, brand, or category or if they tend to be purchased together. We used two different measures of indirect relationship, one based on the meanings of descriptive terms and one based on purchase history. Both correlated with increased likelihood of buying/engaging with seemingly irrelevant results.

The value of “irrelevance”

After performing our statistical analyses, we conducted a pair of experiments to assess the value of including seemingly irrelevant products in our search results. First, we identified 1,500 queries, each associated with one relevant and one irrelevant product, and considered the results of applying five different product selection strategies to all of them.

The first strategy, Optimal, always selects the product that leads to the higher purchase level or engagement level, depending on which we’re measuring. (The engagement/purchase level is the ratio of interactions that resulted in engagement/purchase actions to all the interactions in our data sample.)

Relevant always returns the relevant product, while Irrelevant always returns the irrelevant product. Random arbitrarily selects between the two, and Worst always returns the product that leads to the lower purchase or engagement level. We normalized the results of the other four strategies against Optimal.

Search strategy table
Results of our comparison of five different product selection strategies. “PRatio” is the ratio of purchases to total product searches, "eRatio" the ratio of engagements.

As can be seen in the table at left, there’s a significant gap between both the engagement and purchase levels achieved by selecting only relevant results and the optimal levels, which involve purchase and engagement with irrelevant results.

In another experiment, we used the same 1,500 queries to train three different machine learning models: one learned to maximize relevance, the second to maximize purchase level, and the third to maximize engagement level. Then we built two fusion models, one that combined the relevance model and the engagement model and one that combined the relevance model and the purchase model.

Each fusion model can be tuned to assign different weights to the outputs of the two models that compose it. In the relevance-purchase fusion model, for instance, setting the relevance and purchase-level weights to 1 and 0, respectively, would yield the output of the relevance model alone; setting both models’ weights to .5 would yield an even blend of both models’ outputs. For both fusion models, we swept through a range of weights and charted the results.

Relevance/engagement curve
The trade-off between optimizing relevance and optimizing purchase or engagement levels. In the axis labels, “@1” means that we compared only the top-ranked result of one model to that of the other.

As the chart at right shows, there’s a trade-off between relevance and purchase/engagement level: improving performance on one criterion affects performance on the other. If results do not satisfy the customer’s needs but appear to be relevant, the customer may understand and possibly excuse the shortfall. At the same time, purchase and engagement levels capture a more subjective type of relevance that human annotations cannot assess and may result in more-satisfying product recommendations.

The models we used to assess the trade-off between relevance and purchase/engagement level were fairly crude. A more complex machine learning model should be able to achieve better results, particularly if it is explicitly trained to consider some of the factors we identified previously, such as query length, price, and indirect relation.

While still preliminary, our results provide new insights on how to design product search algorithms and suggest that both objective relevance and purchase/engagement factors should be considered in returning results to customers.

Related content

US, WA, Seattle
The Amazon Devices and Services organization designs, builds and markets Kindle e-readers, Fire Tablets, Fire TV Streaming Media Players and Echo devices. The Device Economics team is looking for an Economist to join our fast paced, start-up environment to help invent the future of product economics. We solve significant business problems in the devices and retail spaces by understanding customer behavior and developing business decision-making frameworks. You will build econometric and machine learning models for causal inference and prediction, using our world class data systems, and apply economic theory to solve business problems in a fast-moving environment. This involves analyzing Amazon Devices and Services customer behavior, and measuring and predicting the lifetime value of existing and future products. We build scalable systems to ensure that our models have broad applicability and large impact. You will work with Scientists, Economists, Product Managers, and Software Developers to provide meaningful feedback about stakeholder problems to inform business solutions and increase the velocity, quality, and scope behind our recommendations. Key job responsibilities Applies expertise in causal modeling to develop econometric/machine learning models to measure the economic value of devices and the business Reviews models and results for other scientists, mentors junior scientists Generates economic insights for the Devices and Services business and work with stakeholders to run the business for effectively Describes strategic importance of vision inside and outside of team. Identifies business opportunities, defines the problem and how to solve it. Engages with scientists, business leadership outside Devices and Services to understand interplay between different business units We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Arlington, VA, USA | Seattle, WA, USA
US, WA, Seattle
Amazon Advertising's Publisher Technologies team is looking for an experienced Applied Scientist with proven research experience in control theory, online machine learning, and/or mechanism design to drive innovative algorithms for ad-delivery at scale. Your work will directly shape pacing, yield optimization, and ad-selection for Amazon's publishers and impact experiences for hundreds of millions of users and devices. About the team Amazon Advertising operates at the intersection of eCommerce, streaming, and advertising, offering a rich array of digital advertising solutions with the goal of helping our customers find and discover anything they want to buy. We help advertisers reach customers across Amazon's owned and operated sites (publishers) across the web and on millions of devices such as Amazon.com, Prime Video, FreeVee, Kindles, Fire tablets, Fire TV, Alexa, Mobile, Twitch, and more. Within Ads, Publisher Technologies is building the next generation of ad-serving products to allow our publishers to monetize their on-demand, streaming, and static content across Amazon’s ad network in a few clicks. Publishers interact directly with our technology, through programmatic APIs to optimize billions of impression opportunities per day. About the role Publisher Technologies is looking to build out our Publisher Ad Server Science + Simulation and Experimentation team to drive innovation across ad-server delivery algorithms for budget pacing, ad-selection, and yield optimization. We seek to ensure the highest quality experiences for Amazon's customers by matching them with most relevant ads while ensuring optimal yield for publishers. As a Senior Applied Scientist, you will research, invent, and apply cutting edge designs and methodologies in control theory, online optimization, and machine learning to improve publisher yield and customer experience. You will work closely with our engineering and product team to design and implement algorithms in production. In addition, you will contribute to the end state vision of AI enhanced ad-delivery. You will be a foundational member of the team that builds a world-class, green-field ad-delivery service for Amazon's video, audio, and display advertising. To be successful in this role, you must be customer obsessed, have a deep technical background in both online algorithms and distributed systems, comfort dealing with ambiguity, an eye for detail, and a passion to identify and solve for practical considerations that occur when complex control-loops have to operate autonomously and reliably to make millisecond level decisions at scale. You are a technical leader with track record of building control theoretic and/or machine learning models in production to drive business KPIs such as budget delivery. If you are interested working on challenging and practical problems that impact hundreds of millions of users and devices and span cutting edge areas of optimization and AI while having fun on a rapidly expanding team, come join us! Key job responsibilities * Developing new statistical, causal, machine learning, and simulation techniques and develop solution prototypes to drive innovation * Developing an understanding of key business metrics / KPIs and providing clear, compelling analysis that shapes the direction of our business * Working with technical and non-technical customers to design experiments, simulations, and communicate results * Collaborating with our dedicated software team to create production implementations for large-scale data analysis * Staying up-to-date with and contributing to the state-of-the-art research and methodologies in the area of advertising algorithms * Presenting research results to our internal research community * Leading training and informational sessions on our science and capabilities * Your contributions will be seen and recognized broadly within Amazon, contributing to the Amazon research corpus and patent portfolio. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Seattle, WA, USA
US, WA, Seattle
The Alexa Economics team is looking for a Senior Economics Manager who is able to provide structure around complex business problems, hone those complex problems into specific, scientific questions, and test those questions to generate insights. The candidate will work with various product, analytics, science, and engineering teams to develop models and algorithms on large scale data, design pilots and measure their impact, and transform successful prototypes into data products at scale. They will lead teams of researchers to produce robust, objective research results and insights which can be communicated to a broad audience inside and outside of Alexa. Key job responsibilities Ideal candidates will work closely with business partners to develop science that solves the most important business challenges. They will work well in a team setting with individuals from diverse disciplines and backgrounds. They will serve as an ambassador for science for business teams, so that leaders are equipped with the right data and mental model to make important business decisions. Ideal candidates will own the development of scientific models and manage the data analysis, modeling, and experimentation that is necessary for estimating and validating models. They will be customer centric – clearly communicating scientific approaches and findings to business leaders, listening to and incorporate their feedback, and delivering successful scientific solutions. A day in the life - Review new technical approaches to understand Engagement and associated benefits to Alexa. - Partner with Engineering and Product teams to inject econometric insights and models into customer-facing products. - Help business teams understand the key causal inputs that drive business outcome objectives. About the team The Alexa Engagement and Economics and Team uses data, analytics, economics, statistics, and machine learning to measure, report, and track business outputs and growth. We are a team that is obsessed with understanding customer behaviors, and leveraging all aspects from customers behaviors with Alexa and Amazon to develop and deliver solutions that can drive Alexa growth and long-term business success. We use causal inference to identify business optimization and product opportunities. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Bellevue, WA, USA | Seattle, WA, USA
US, WA, Bellevue
We are seeking a passionate, talented, and inventive individual to join the Applied AI team and help build industry-leading technologies that customers will love. This team offers a unique opportunity to make a significant impact on the customer experience and contribute to the design, architecture, and implementation of a cutting-edge product. The mission of the Applied AI team is to enable organizations within Worldwide Amazon.com Stores to accelerate the adoption of AI technologies across various parts of our business. We are looking for an Applied Scientist to join our Applied AI team to work on LLM-based solutions. Key job responsibilities You will be responsible for developing and maintaining the systems and tools that enable us to accelerate knowledge operations and work in the intersection of Science and Engineering. You will push the boundaries of ML and Generative AI techniques to scale the inputs for hundreds of billions of dollars of annual revenue for our eCommerce business. If you have a passion for AI technologies, a drive to innovate and a desire to make a meaningful impact, we invite you to become a valued member of our team. A day in the life We are seeking an experienced Scientist who combines superb technical, research, analytical and leadership capabilities with a demonstrated ability to get the right things done quickly and effectively. This person must be comfortable working with a team of top-notch developers and collaborating with our research teams. We’re looking for someone who innovates, and loves solving hard problems. You will be expected to have an established background in building highly scalable systems and system design, excellent project management skills, great communication skills, and a motivation to achieve results in a fast-paced environment. You should be somebody who enjoys working on complex problems, is customer-centric, and feels strongly about building good software as well as making that software achieve its operational goals. About the team On our team you will push the boundaries of ML and Generative AI techniques to scale the inputs for hundreds of billions of dollars of annual revenue for our eCommerce business. If you have a passion for AI technologies, a drive to innovate and a desire to make a meaningful impact, we invite you to become a valued member of our team. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Bellevue, WA, USA
US, WA, Bellevue
We are looking for detail-oriented, organized, and responsible individuals who are eager to learn how to work with large and complicated data sets. Some knowledge of econometrics, as well as basic familiarity with Python is necessary, and experience with SQL and UNIX would be a plus. These are full-time positions at 40 hours per week, with compensation being awarded on an hourly basis. You will learn how to build data sets and perform applied econometric analysis at Internet speed collaborating with economists, scientists, and product managers. These skills will translate well into writing applied chapters in your dissertation and provide you with work experience that may help you with placement. Roughly 85% of previous cohorts have converted to full time economics employment at Amazon. If you are interested, please send your CV to our mailing list at econ-internship@amazon.com. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Arlington, VA, USA | Bellevue, WA, USA | Seattle, WA, USA
US, WA, Seattle
The ASFS Team is hiring an Intern in Economics. We are looking for detail-oriented, organized, and responsible individuals who are eager to learn how to work with large and complicated data sets. Knowledge of econometrics and macroeconomics, as well as familiarity with Python, Matlab, or R is necessary. This is a full-time position at 40 hours per week, with compensation being awarded on an hourly basis. You will use internal and external data to estimate macroeconometric models to answer critical business questions, also you will have the opportunity to collaborate with economists and data scientists. Roughly 85% of interns from previous cohorts have converted to full time economics employment at Amazon. If you are interested, please send your CV to our mailing list at econ-internship@amazon.com. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Bellevue, WA, USA | New York City, NY, USA | Seattle, WA, USA
US, WA, Bellevue
As an Applied Scientist on our Learning and Development team, you will play a critical role in driving the design, development, and delivery of learning programs and initiatives aimed at enhancing leadership and associate development within the organization. You will leverage your expertise in learning science, data analysis, and statistical model design to create impactful learning journey roadmap that align with organizational goals and priorities. Key job responsibilities 1) Research and Analysis: Conduct research on learning and development trends, theories, and best practices related to leadership and associate development. Analyze data to identify learning needs, performance gaps, and opportunities for improvement within the organization. Use data-driven insights to inform the design and implementation of learning interventions. 2) Program Design and Development: Collaborate with cross-functional teams to develop comprehensive learning programs focused on leadership development and associate growth. Design learning experiences using evidence-based instructional strategies, adult learning principles, and innovative technologies. Create engaging and interactive learning materials, including e-learning modules, instructor-led workshops, and multimedia resources. 3) Evaluation and Continuous Improvement: Develop evaluation frameworks to assess the effectiveness and impact of learning programs on leadership development and associate performance. Collect and analyze feedback from participants and stakeholders to identify strengths, areas for improvement, and future learning needs. Iterate on learning interventions based on evaluation results and feedback to continuously improve program outcomes. 4) Thought Leadership and Collaboration: Serve as a subject matter expert on learning science, instructional design, and leadership development within the organization. Collaborate with stakeholders across the company to align learning initiatives with strategic priorities and business objectives. Share knowledge and best practices with colleagues to foster a culture of continuous learning and development. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Bellevue, WA, USA | Nashville, TN, USA
US, WA, Seattle
Amazon Web Services (AWS) is building a world-class marketing organization, and we are looking for an experienced Economist to join the central data and science organization for AWS Marketing. This candidate will develop innovative solutions to measure the return on marketing investments. They will work closely with business leaders, scientists, and engineers to translate business and functional requirements into concrete deliverables, including the design, development, testing, and deployment of innovative measurement solutions. They will interact with functional leaders owning events (e.g. re:Invent, summits, webinars), paid media (paid search, paid social, display), AWS-owned channels (email, website, console) as well as lead management organization to drive the development, fine-tuning and adoption of the consistent measurement framework across these diverse initiatives. We seek candidates with an entrepreneurial spirit who want to make a big impact on AWS growth. They will develop strong working relationships and thrive in a collaborative team environment. They will have the creativity, curiosity, and strong judgment to work on high-impact, high-visibility products to improve the experience of AWS leads and customers. Key job responsibilities - Apply your expertise in causal inference and ML to develop systems to measure B2B marketing impact - Develop and execute science products from concept, prototype to production incorporating feedback from customers, scientists and business leaders - Identify new opportunities for leveraging economic insights and models in the marketing space - Write technical white papers and business-facing documents to clearly explain complex technical concepts to audiences with diverse business/scientific backgrounds We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Arlington, VA, USA | Austin, TX, USA | New York City, NY, USA | Seattle, WA, USA
US, GA, Atlanta
Looking for your next challenge? North America Sort Centers (NASC) are experiencing growth and looking for a skilled, highly motivated Data Scientist to join the NASC Engineering Data, Product and Simulation Team. The Sort Center network is the critical Middle-Mile solution in the Amazon Transportation Services (ATS) group, linking Fulfillment Centers to the Last Mile. The experience of our customers is dependent on our ability to efficiently execute volume flow through the middle-mile network. Key job responsibilities The Senior Data Scientist will design and implement solutions to address complex business questions using simulation. In this role, you will apply advanced analysis techniques and statistical concepts to draw insights from massive datasets, and create intuitive simulations and data visualizations. You can contribute to each layer of a data solution – you work closely with process design engineers, business intelligence engineers and technical product managers to obtain relevant datasets and create simulation models, and review key results with business leaders and stakeholders. Your work exhibits a balance between scientific validity and business practicality. On this team, you will have a large impact on the entire NASC organization, with lots of opportunity to learn and grow within the NASC Engineering team. This role will be the first dedicated simulation expert, so you will have an exceptional opportunity to define and drive vision for simulation best practices on our team. To be successful in this role, you must be able to turn ambiguous business questions into clearly defined problems, develop quantifiable metrics and deliver results that meet high standards of data quality, security, and privacy. About the team NASC Engineering’s Product and Analytics Team’s sole objective is to develop tools for under the roof simulation and optimization, supporting the needs of our internal and external stakeholders (i.e Process Design Engineering, NASC Engineering, ACES, Finance, Safety and Operations). We develop data science tools to evaluate what-if design and operations scenarios for new and existing sort centers to understand their robustness, stability, scalability, and cost-effectiveness. We conceptualize new data science solutions, using optimization and machine learning platforms, to analyze new and existing process, identify and reduce non-value added steps, and increase overall performance and rate. We work by interfacing with various functional teams to test and pilot new hardware/software solutions. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Atlanta, GA, USA | Bellevue, WA, USA
US, WA, Bellevue
Amazon’s Middle Mile Planning & Optimization team is looking for an exceptional Sr. Applied Scientist to solve complex optimization problems that ensure we exceed customer delivery promise expectations and minimize overall operational cost while supporting Amazon’s rapid growth globally. We use cutting edge technologies in large-scale optimization, predictive analytics, and generative AI to optimize the flow of packages within our network to efficiently match network capacity with shipment demand. Our services already handle thousands of requests per second, make business decisions impacting billions of dollars a year, and improve the delivery experience for millions of online shoppers. That said, this remains a fast-growing business and our journey has just started. Our mission is to build the most efficient and optimal transportation solution on the planet, using our technology and engineering muscle as our biggest advantage. Key job responsibilities You will work closely with product managers, research scientists, business/operations leaders, and technical leadership to build capabilities that transform our transportation network. This includes analyzing big data, building end-to-end workflows, prototype optimization/simulation models, and launch production capabilities. You will have exposure to senior leadership as you communicate results and provide scientific guidance to the business. Your insights will be a key influencer of our product strategy and roadmap and your experimental research will inform our future investment areas. About the team You will join the Surface Research Science (SRS) team, which is the science partner of the Middle-Mile Planning & Optimization tech organization. SRS is working on a fascinating range of problems, including some of the hardest and largest optimization, simulation, and prediction problems in the industry. Examples are long-term and short-term demand forecasting, capacity planning, driver scheduling, vehicle routing, and equipment rebalancing problems. We are open to hiring candidates to work out of one of the following locations: Bellevue, WA, USA